Issue Brief: An Examination of Payments in Lieu of Taxes

November 16, 2026

Click here to read the full report

Executive Summary

All 50 states exempt property owned by charitable nonprofits, such as universities, religious institutions and hospitals, from property taxes. State laws establish exemption rules, although 17 states let local governments decide which nonprofits qualify within certain categories.1 However, these nonprofits still benefit from local taxpayer-funded services such as police, fire protection, and street maintenance, thereby shifting the cost of funding those services to other property owners. To help offset these costs, some local governments seek voluntary contributions from tax-exempt property owners.

Payments in Lieu of Taxes (PILOTs) are payments made by tax-exempt entities to units of local government to make up for some of the forgone revenue from property taxes. These arrangements take different forms but are traditionally defined by the Lincoln Institute of Land Policy as voluntary payments made by tax-exempt nonprofits to local governments as a substitute for property taxes.2 In some places, the state makes these payments to local governments instead. This issue brief describes both kinds.

Facing rising costs and flat or shrinking revenue bases, local governments around the nation are increasingly exploring PILOT agreements with nonprofit organizations to supplement their revenues, support service delivery and reduce property tax reliance.
Discussions of payments in lieu of taxes are particularly relevant in Illinois now as the state House of Representatives approved legislation in April 2026 creating a PILOT agreement for the Chicago Bears’ new stadium in Arlington Heights that would freeze the property’s assessed value for up to 40 years in exchange for negotiated payments to local taxing districts, potentially saving the team more than $1.5 billion in property taxes.3 However, the Senate has not approved the bill and there are ongoing discussions about the nature of a Bears Stadium economic development package.

This issue brief examines to what extent PILOTs can serve as a stable and reliable revenue
source for funding local services. It looks at three examples:

  • City program: Boston asks large nonprofits to make voluntary payments.
  • Negotiated arrangement: Evanston, Illinois negotiated an agreement with
    Northwestern University for the University to make a series of payments to the City as
    part of the City’s approval of its new football stadium.
  • State program: The State of Connecticut pays cities and towns to make up for property the State exempts from taxes.

Summary of Findings 

PILOTs have the potential to serve as supplemental revenue to local budgets, but how much they generate and how steady and reliable this revenue is depends on how the PILOTs are set up, whether payments are voluntary or required by law, and how long the commitments last. Seven key findings emerge:

  • PILOTs usually generate modest amounts of revenue. Cash from nonprofits equaled about 1% of Boston’s and Evanston’s operating budgets. Most places that receive PILOTs nationwide report similarly small amounts.
  • Allowing in-kind or community benefit services in place of cash reduces the cash governments receive. Boston lets nonprofits count the value of services they provide to residents, such as scholarships for local students, toward up to half of what the City requests. In FY2025, nonprofits covered 76% of the City’s request this way, but cash covered only 27%.
  • Longer agreements make payments more predictable, but they tend to come with limiting conditions. Northwestern University’s commitment to Evanston runs for 15 years, replacing earlier gifts that stopped in 2022 and 2023. Because it was made as part of a zoning approval, not under Illinois’ law on service payment agreements, the law’s five-year limit does not apply. The payments hold only if the legal and regulatory environment stays substantially the same as in 2023, and the agreement does not define what change would end them.
  • State-funded PILOT programs can provide substantially more revenue to local governments than voluntary agreements, but payments may fluctuate annually depending on state funding decisions. Connecticut illustrates this approach. The state provides grants to municipalities to compensate for tax-exempt properties, recognizing that colleges, hospitals and state facilities serve residents beyond their host communities. Connecticut funds these payments through a dedicated share of state sales tax revenue. The state's grant to New Haven equals approximately 14% of the city's General Fund budget, demonstrating the potential fiscal significance of state-funded PILOTs. However, the amount municipalities receive remains dependent on state funding decisions.
  • Illinois law limits PILOT agreements. Section 15-30 of the Illinois Property Tax Code allows voluntary agreements for up to five years at a time.
  • PILOTS do not necessarily benefit overlapping governments. Because multiple local governments levy taxes on the same property, a payment to one government, such as a municipality, does not necessarily benefit other taxing bodies, such as school districts.
  • Interest in PILOTs is growing, but there is no clear sign of a national trend. The most recent national count from 2012 identified PILOTs in at least 218 localities in 28 states.

For Illinois local governments, PILOT agreements offer a potential source of additional revenue but are unlikely to provide substantial or reliable fiscal relief under current law. Payments are voluntary, limited in duration and generally benefit only the governments receiving them, leaving other overlapping taxing districts without additional revenue. PILOTs can therefore best be viewed as a supplemental revenue source rather than a significant solution to local government fiscal challenges.

Footnotes 

1 Daphne A. Kenyon and Adam H. Langley, Payments in Lieu of Taxes: Balancing Municipal and Nonprofit
Interests (Cambridge, MA: Lincoln Institute of Land Policy, 2010), 2, 10–11,
https://www.lincolninst.edu/publications/policy-focus-reports/payments-in-lieu-taxes/.  
2 Kenyon and Langley, Payments in Lieu of Taxes, 2, 6.
3 An alternative proposal would establish a publicly owned stadium authority, making the stadium generally
exempt from property taxes while leaving surrounding private development taxable. Cook County Treasurer.
Illinois Megaproject Bill: A Bears Incentive with Wide Property Tax Ramifications, May 26, 2026.